Top Ad
I DIG Radio
www.idigradio.com
Listen live to the best music from around the world!
I DIG Style
www.idigstyle.com
Learn about the latest fashion styles and more...

Ian Chappell on how Australia should discuss taking a knee: 'It's got to be ongoing'

Written by 
Published in Cricket
Sunday, 15 November 2020 20:28

Australia's men's team came in for strong criticism from Michael Holding for not taking the knee on their tour of England earlier this year and coach Justin Langer admitted the squad had not given it enough of a discussion. The game in Australia continues to debate how to acknowledge the Black Lives Matter movement, with teams and players making individual decisions during the ongoing WBBL, and the Australia men's team opting for an Aboriginal Barefoot Circle against India. ESPNcricinfo spoke to former Australia captain Ian Chappell about his views on what should take place.

You come to this issue from talking a lot to Michael Holding about it in particular?

I was very impressed with both Michael and Ebony [Rainford-Brent]. I thought it was really very powerful and stuff that needed to be said. I found it also educational - you figured there has probably been a fair bit of discrimination going on, but when you hear it first-hand and exactly how bad it is, it really hits home. I regularly speak to Mikey about things. Previously it was more to do with what was going on in America, he'd send me little clips or notes about events. So he sends me a lot, but more to do with America than with cricket.

So how would you address the question of taking the knee, both personally but also as a captain leading a discussion?

My personal view is that if I was playing now, I would be doing something, whether it is taking a knee or not, I'd be letting it be known that things need to improve. As a captain I think it's very much an individual thing and I'd call the team together and say 'okay, what do you guys want to do' and if it was all 'we'll take a knee' then fine, we're all taking a knee. But if it was some do want to and some don't, I'd be saying, 'well alright, you do what you feel you have to do and it's an individual decision, but you won't cop any flak for that decision'.

If I was taking that route, before I made it public, I would be dealing with the Board and saying 'look, this is the situation, some players are going to take a knee and others aren't, and I don't want anybody to be punished for taking a knee - if that's going to happen then there'll be a problem'. I think that's really important, because you don't want guys suddenly disappearing out of the team because they're taking a stand.

Sounds like what we have seen in the WBBL, with some players and clubs taking the knee but others choosing not to?

Exactly. That's the first thing you do, sit down and talk about it. But I think in any situation where you're taking a stand, I think it's got to be an individual thing, and I don't think anybody should be forced to do something against their will.

How much do you think it is incumbent upon cricketers to have a decent level of understanding of events going on around the world, whether it is to do with racism or other matters?

Certainly in the past I would say it was easier to make a stand or express an opinion once you'd retired, rather than while you were still playing, and I think the prevailing attitude was that if I'm going to do something, I'll do it after I've retired. That being said, apart from Apartheid, there weren't too many issues of that nature. In early 1971 at Newlands in a first-class game, both sides walked off the field after one ball of the match to protest the South African government's stance, and that included guys like Barry Richards, Clive Rice, Graeme and Peter Pollock, Mike Procter and Denis Lindsay. That was a brave thing to do, but the prevailing attitude was 'let's not get political while we're playing'. I think in these circumstances it is probably easier to make your feelings known as a player, because it's happening worldwide in so many different areas of life.

How would you respond to concerns about how the Australian men's team might be received if some took the knee and some did not?

You discover in life that the people who like you, it basically doesn't matter what you do, they'll still like you. And the people who don't like you, same thing. So for people taking a knee they'll get criticised and you've just got to forget about it. Whatever you do, you'll get some critics, of the people who take a knee and of the people who don't take a knee. But I'm with Mikey on the fact that it's something that needs to be ongoing. It's no good just doing it that Test series in England against the West Indies, and then it's forgotten. It's got to be an ongoing thing, because it's an ongoing problem.

What is your view on how far away Australian cricket is from reflecting the diversity of Australia?

I think Cricket Australia has done more in recent times to try to address that problem. It's only in very recent times that much has been done to try to attract Aboriginals to the game. I don't think Australia took that opportunity until recently, but there have since been genuine attempts to improve that situation. It's a very diverse country and there's no doubt that cricket doesn't reflect that diversity yet. Whether it will one day, it will have to, otherwise the game will be dying. If you're going to totally rely on the Anglo heritage you're going to be in trouble down the track.

I think that's really the first step. The kids going to the cricket have got to look out on the field and see diversity on the field. Thanks to the BBL and the WBBL they are seeing more, because overseas players are coming in. But I think that's an important part of the process…if they go to the cricket and they don't see anyone they can relate to out on the field, they're going to think 'well, this game's not for us'.

Lastly, what's your perspective on how, as national men's captains, Aaron Finch and Tim Paine, should discuss the issue with the team?

The best way to go about it would be to have a players' association level discussion. So you're talking about all players, male and female, discuss it there. You're probably going to come to the same conclusions about it needing to be an individual choice, but I think by doing that and letting it be known that the thing is being discussed by all players, that's taking a bit of the onus off the captains. So I think that would ease the situation a bit if it's made public that 'this is a broad discussion we've had as players, male and female and this is the conclusion we've come to'. I think by doing it that way, one you make it clear to the public that it's not the captains just saying 'this is how it's going to be done', and also it's sending a message to CA that 'we've given this a lot of thought and this is the solution we've come up with ourselves'.

Read 717 times

Soccer

Man City face 'tough' season after late collapse

Man City face 'tough' season after late collapse

EmailPrintOpen Extended ReactionsPep Guardiola said Manchester City are in for a "tough" season afte...

Man City need more than Haaland as season sits on knife's edge

Man City need more than Haaland as season sits on knife's edge

EmailPrintOpen Extended ReactionsMANCHESTER, England -- For 75 minutes on Tuesday night, Manchester...

10-man PSG drop to 26th in narrow loss to Bayern

10-man PSG drop to 26th in narrow loss to Bayern

Bayern Munich battled past 10-man Paris Saint-Germain 1-0 in the Champions League thanks to Kim Min-...

2026 FIFA


2028 LOS ANGELES OLYMPIC

UEFA

2024 PARIS OLYMPIC


Basketball

Giannis out vs. Heat due to pregame knee issue

Giannis out vs. Heat due to pregame knee issue

EmailPrintOpen Extended ReactionsMIAMI -- Milwaukee Bucks star Giannis Antetokounmpo is out for Tues...

Sources: Kings closing in on deal for Crowder

Sources: Kings closing in on deal for Crowder

EmailPrintOpen Extended ReactionsFree-agent forward Jae Crowder is close to a deal with the Sacramen...

Baseball

Dodgers split $46M from record MLB playoff pool

Dodgers split $46M from record MLB playoff pool

EmailPrintOpen Extended ReactionsNEW YORK -- A full postseason share for the World Series champion L...

Starter or reliever? Stay with the Phillies or go elsewhere? All-Star Jeff Hoffman opens up on free agency

Starter or reliever? Stay with the Phillies or go elsewhere? All-Star Jeff Hoffman opens up on free agency

EmailPrintOpen Extended ReactionsJeff Hoffman is one of the most sought-after relievers in this offs...

Sports Leagues

  • FIFA

    Fédération Internationale de Football Association
  • NBA

    National Basketball Association
  • ATP

    Association of Tennis Professionals
  • MLB

    Major League Baseball
  • ITTF

    International Table Tennis Federation
  • NFL

    Nactional Football Leagues
  • FISB

    Federation Internationale de Speedball

About Us

I Dig® is a leading global brand that makes it more enjoyable to surf the internet, conduct transactions and access, share, and create information.  Today I Dig® attracts millions of users every month.r

 

Phone: (800) 737. 6040
Fax: (800) 825 5558
Website: www.idig.com
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Affiliated